
What the 50% rule counts and leaves out
The 50% rule in real estate is a screening shortcut for rental property. It sets a year of operating costs at half the gross rent, so you can judge a deal before you price each cost.
Gross rent is the full rent before any costs. The mortgage sits outside the 50%, and it comes out of the half that is left.
BiggerPockets puts taxes and insurance inside the half, along with utilities, repairs and vacancy. Guides split on management, and we count it, because a manager's fee comes out of the rent.
- Vacancy: the rent you lose while the property sits empty.
- Management: a manager's fee, usually a share of the rent.
- Tax and insurance: the yearly property tax bill and a landlord policy.
- Maintenance: repairs and replacements, averaged over the years.
- Left out: the mortgage, income tax and depreciation.
A real example from a Homesage.ai report
We pulled one single-family property for sale in St. Louis County, Missouri, from Homesage.ai Investment Property Search. Its verified rent is 0.78% of the price a month.
| A year of costs | Maintenance 1% | Maintenance 2% | Maintenance 4% |
|---|---|---|---|
| List price | $199,900 | $199,900 | $199,900 |
| Verified rent a month | $1,563 | $1,563 | $1,563 |
| Rent a year | $18,756 | $18,756 | $18,756 |
| The 50% rule's estimate | $9,378 | $9,378 | $9,378 |
| Vacancy at 6.6% | -$1,238 | -$1,238 | -$1,238 |
| Management at 10% of rent collected | -$1,752 | -$1,752 | -$1,752 |
| Property tax at 1.14% of price | -$2,279 | -$2,279 | -$2,279 |
| Landlord insurance | -$2,085 | -$2,085 | -$2,085 |
| Maintenance | -$1,999 | -$3,998 | -$7,996 |
| Line-by-line costs | $9,353 | $11,352 | $15,350 |
| Share of the rent | 49.9% | 60.5% | 81.8% |
| Gap against the rule's estimate | $25 under | $1,974 over | $5,972 over |
Verified rent here means the rent advertised on a recent rental listing for this property, checked in our listing data. No lease stands behind it.

At 1% maintenance, costs take 49.9% of the rent, almost exactly the rule's half. At 2%, they take 60.5%. The rule then misses $1,974 a year, about $165 a month.
The property sits outside the City of St. Louis, so tax uses St. Louis County's 1.14% effective rate from SmartAsset's Missouri tax data. Other inputs match the illustration below.

Testing the 50% rule in real estate
Here is the test on a hypothetical St. Louis property. It is priced at $200,000 and rents for $1,600 a month, round figures we invented to show the method.
| A year of costs | Maintenance 1% | Maintenance 2% | Maintenance 4% |
|---|---|---|---|
| Rent a year | $19,200 | $19,200 | $19,200 |
| Vacancy at 6.6% | -$1,267 | -$1,267 | -$1,267 |
| Management at 10% of rent collected | -$1,793 | -$1,793 | -$1,793 |
| Property tax at 1.02% of price | -$2,040 | -$2,040 | -$2,040 |
| Landlord insurance | -$2,085 | -$2,085 | -$2,085 |
| Maintenance | -$2,000 | -$4,000 | -$8,000 |
| Line-by-line costs | $9,185 | $11,185 | $15,185 |
| Share of the rent | 47.8% | 58.3% | 79.1% |
| The 50% rule's estimate | $9,600 | $9,600 | $9,600 |
| Left before the mortgage, a month | $835 | $668 | $335 |
Vacancy is 6.6%, the St. Louis metro rate for Q2 2026 in the Census Bureau's metro vacancy table. Its margin of error is 3.4 points. Management is 10%, the middle of the 8% to 12% of rent that SmartAsset reports.
Tax uses the 1.02% effective rate for St. Louis city from SmartAsset's Missouri tax data. Insurance starts from Missouri's $1,668 average homeowners premium for 2022, in NAIC figures from the Insurance Information Institute.
Landlord policies cost about 25% more than that owner-occupied premium, according to the Insurance Information Institute's guide to renting out a home. That puts this property at $2,085 a year.
Fannie Mae's maintenance guide budgets 1% to 4% of value a year and points homes over 30 years old toward 4%. At 1%, the rule overstates this property's costs by $415 a year. At 2%, it misses $1,585 a year, or $132 a month.
At 2% maintenance, 77 of 86 St. Louis properties we checked would cost more than half their rent to run.
St. Louis rentals that fit the rule
Tax and maintenance rise with the price, and insurance stays flat. So the rule fits only above a certain rent-to-price ratio. On a $200,000 St. Louis property, line-by-line costs fall to half the rent at these levels.
| Maintenance budget | Rent needed, share of price a month | Properties at or above | Properties below |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1% of price | 0.75% | 52 | 34 |
| 2% of price | 0.99% | 9 | 77 |
| 4% of price | 1.48% | 0 | 86 |
We counted 86 properties for sale in St. Louis priced $150,000 to $250,000 with a verified rent, out of 271 in that price band, on 2026-10-19. At 2% maintenance, the line runs from about 1.08% at $150,000 to 0.94% at $250,000, because insurance is a flat cost.
Verified rent here means the rent advertised on a recent rental listing for each property, checked in our listing data. No lease stands behind it.
Below the line, the 50% rule in real estate understates your costs. Above it, the rule builds in a cushion.
Check the 50% rule in 5 steps

- Take half the yearly rent. That is the rule's cost estimate, $9,600 on a $1,600 monthly rent.
- Price each cost line by line. Use your metro's vacancy rate, your county's tax rate and a landlord insurance quote.
- Match maintenance to the property. Fannie Mae's range runs from 1% of value for a newer home to 4% for one over 30 years old.
- Divide the total by the rent. A result above 50% means the rule understates your costs.
- Subtract the mortgage from what is left. Our guide to the return on a rental property carries that cash flow through to the return.
What changes the answer
Rent against price drives the result. A property renting for 0.8% of its price a month carries a higher cost share than one renting for 1.2%. Tax and maintenance follow the price, while vacancy and management follow the rent.
Vacancy changes by metro. In the same Census table, Q2 2026 rental vacancy ran from 0.5% in San Jose to 22% in Buffalo. At Buffalo's rate, the illustration property at 2% maintenance would spend 72.1% of its rent.
Insurance changes by state. The 2022 average premium was $2,677 in Florida and $893 in Oregon. Swap either into the 2% column with the same 25% landlord loading and costs take 64.8% or 53.2% of the rent.
Managing the property yourself removes the 10% fee. At 2% maintenance, costs then fall to 48.9% of the rent, and the work moves to you.
Common 50% rule mistakes to avoid
- Using the rule on a low-rent property: At 0.8% of price a month and 2% maintenance, the illustration property costs 58.3% of its rent. The rule misses $1,585 a year, so price each line when the ratio sits under about 1%.
- Putting the mortgage inside the half: The 50% covers operating costs only. Take 12 months of loan payments out of the other half, or your cash flow reads too high.
- Ignoring the age of the property: At 4% maintenance, the illustration property spends 79.1% of its rent. Match the maintenance line to the age and property condition before you trust any shortcut.
- Treating the rule as a budget: The 50% is an average over years, and one new furnace can break a single year's budget. A verified rent is also one advertised rent, so check 3 to 5 comparable rentals.
Estimated values. Not investment advice. Data as of 2026-10-28.
Frequently asked questions
Does the 50% rule include the mortgage?
Does the 50% rule include property management?
Is the 50% rule accurate?
What is the difference between the 50% rule and the 1% rule?
How do you calculate the 50% rule?
Ask Sage for rentals to test
Sage, our assistant, finds properties for sale in any US city from inside the AI tool you already use. It shows the rent where one is on file, so you can price each cost before you trust the 50% rule.
- Homesage.ai Investment Property Search counts for properties for sale in St. Louis, Missouri, pulled 2026-10-19. The cost math is ours.
- Homesage.ai Investment Property Search, one property for sale in St. Louis County, Missouri, with a verified rent, pulled 2026-10-28. The cost math is ours.
- Illustration property: round, invented figures to show the method, not a real listing.
- BiggerPockets, real estate investing rules of thumb, updated 2021-06-02.
- US Census Bureau rental vacancy rates for the 75 largest metros, Table 4, Q2 2026.
- SmartAsset, how much property managers charge, published 2022-07-07.
- SmartAsset, Missouri property tax calculator, read 2026-10-19 and 2026-10-29.
- Insurance Information Institute, homeowners and renters insurance facts, average premiums by state for 2022.
- Insurance Information Institute, coverage for renting out your home.
- Fannie Mae, how to build your maintenance and repair budget.